Episode Transcript
[00:00:00] Speaker A: For more information on Ancient Dragon Zen Gate, please visit our website at www.ancientdragon.org. our teachings are offered to the community through the generosity of our supporters. To make a donation online, please visit our website.
[00:00:16] Speaker B: Tonto, Head of Practice, is going to offer the Dharma talk.
And thank you for doing that, as well as everything else.
Look forward to your. Donald.
[00:00:31] Speaker C: Good morning.
It's good to see all of you. It's really good to see Jason. It's been too long since we've seen him. And the last time I saw his son, Ashwin. Ashwin was in a stroller. So, anyway, here we are.
I've been introduced. So I guess I'm supposed to give a Dharma talk. I'd better come up with one pretty quick.
My thoughts about the Dharma talk sort of disappeared during the sitting. I was appreciating just this sitting here, breathing deeply in a relaxed way, and just opening to being alive, experiencing this moment, being aware of experiencing the surroundings, my posture, the bodily sensations, thoughts, emotions, some desires, and just the sense of being here in this moment, in this.
In this vast, seamless hole of this moment.
And feeling, having these.
All these thoughts and feelings and desires, but also feeling free of them in a way, not having to get rid of them.
This practice of letting go of our thoughts, these fabrications that come and go, come and go, allows us to step free of these dualistic patterns of thinking and feeling in terms of like and judgments, like and dislike, good or bad, right, wrong, should, shouldn't, better, worse. And when we do that, when we're not projecting that on there, we're just here, just experiencing this moment free of that.
That's what the tradition in Dogen, for example, called our original face.
And it's the practice realization of culminated perfect enlightenment.
So it's a pretty great thing. It's very simple. It just happens right here.
We're not having to get somewhere else to have a special understanding or to develop some great virtue and get rid of our evil thoughts, anything like that. We can wake up like this, right in the middle of our doubts and fears, our anger, our desires, cravings, which is pretty great. But sometimes those habits come back and they can even affect our practice so that our practice becomes a matter of trying to fix ourselves.
And then we do start thinking about how, okay, how am I going to get rid of. I have to start having good thoughts. I have to get rid of these bad thoughts.
I have to understand something. I have to figure this out.
And when I've figured out what emptiness is and what suchness are and so on. Then I'll be free.
Everything will be great from then on. It'll be permanent forever. Yeah, yeah, maybe not. Our tradition has said that that sort of program is self improvement isn't how we come to liberation, that we come to liberation just as we are right here, sitting with everything that we are and with everything else without trying to improve or fix anything.
So these are, you know, that practice is fixing things, working some sort of self improvement, working toward some state of enlightenment in the future as opposed to this being here right now as you are in this boundless, complete world is something that is familiar to our tradition since a long time ago.
And so I was looking at a koan which resonated with me about this very issue.
So we'll see what I have to say about that and see if anything about it resonates with you.
This is case one from the Blue Cliff record about Bodhidharma meets Emperor Wu.
And it goes.
Emperor Wu of Liang asked the great Master Bodhidharma what is the highest meaning of the holy truths? Bodhidharma said, emptiness without holiness.
The Emperor said, well then, who is facing me? And Bodhidharma replied, I don't know. The Emperor did not understand. And after this, Bodhidharma crossed the Yangtze river and came to the Kingdom of Wei and went from there to Shaolin Temple, where he sat in a cave overlooking Shaolin for nine months in Zazen. And later the Emperor brought this exchange up to Master Qi and asked him about it. And Master Zhu asked, does your master know who this man is? And the Emperor said, I don't know.
Master Ritir said, he is the Mahasattva Avalokiteshvara, transmitting the Buddha mind seal.
The Emperor felt regretful, so he wanted to send an emissary to go invite Bodhidharma to return. And Master Jura told him, you, Majesty, don't say that you'll send someone to fetch him back. Even if everyone in the whole kingdom were to go after him, he wouldn't return.
That's a story.
So just as some background, Emperor Wu, you know, there's very little known about Bodhidharma. So little that until fairly recently, probably most academic scholars doubted that he ever existed. He was just this figure created by the tradition to be the basis for stories like these and to not scriptures, but teaching documents that that were created by some unknown person. Nowadays, people think he probably did exist.
Some pretty suggestive records of his having existed, but the rest is legend.
On the other hand, we know a fair amount about Emperor Wu of Liang. He was the Emperor of Liang, and under his reign, Liang became a very prosperous and stable kingdom.
Emperor Wu was a Confucian and he did a lot of work, his expressions of Confucian virtue. He extended the examinations for the bureaucracy to the aristocrats and nobility within Liang. He required them to study for and sit for the exams, and he abolished capital punishment.
But beyond being the Son of Heaven, the apex of society, the highest secular figure there was, he was also a very devout Buddhist, and he showed great generosity to the Sangha, building lots of monasteries, funding, supporting many monks, supporting ordination platforms so that people could ordain.
The description of him is that he practiced the Buddhadharma humbly and diligently, and he studied a great deal, especially he studied in particular with a couple of scholars of who are experts in doctrine of two realities of form and emptiness, the particular and the absolute and the universal, if you like.
And he wrote a treatise that was very well regarded and very widely read. And he went into the monasteries several times.
And although he had a certain sort of twist on that, he would arrange for the court to bail him out by making huge donations to the saga to let him come back to court.
But he was also famous for from time to time, putting his monk's robes back on and preaching to the court.
So all of this resulted in his being known as the Bodhisattva Emperor or the Buddhaheart Emperor.
As further background, I think it will be helpful. Yuan Wu, one of the compilers of the Blue Cliff Record, the one who added poems and commentaries to Xuedou's original collection of 100 koans, gives some more background. He says that, you know, Emperor Wu was always interested in whenever a new famous teacher would come into town.
And when he heard that Bodhidharma there was this new Indian monk, he was particularly interested in Indian culture. When he heard that Bodhidharma was in town, he invited him to come to the court.
Bodhidharma came. It's not clear to me whether he wanted to hear be taught by Bodhidharma or did he want to debate with Bodhidharma. Maybe it was a mix of the two things.
So, you know, invite the gunslinger, new gunslinger in town, just to so both of you can test each other. That sounds like a very Zen tradition kind of thing to do.
So when Bodhidharma shows up, you can imagine this scene of this court with all these people surrounding the emperor and Bodhidharma. Everyone's in fancy court dress.
Everyone who comes before the Emperor has to do kowtow. He has to do three prostrations, touching his head to the floor three times, a total of nine head to the floor.
And all this dignity with the emperor sitting up on a high chair. And then in comes what the tradition always pictures and what Shuido and Yuanwu would have pictured. I think this barbarian from India, he's not wearing Chinese dress. He's not wearing the gown and the Koromo and the Okesai. He's wearing the monks and the robes of an Indian monk.
And he's kind of bug eyed and round eyed and their eyes really spread apart. He has a sort of fierce expression on his face and a huge red beard because he dyed it. Or at least that's how people always thought about him because they thought maybe he was from South Asia, but we think he was really a Persian from Central Asia. And all those people from the tribal lands, their beards red. So that's this out, that's Bodhidharma coming in. So the tradition sees him as this dignified, accomplished emperor and this outlandish monk, foreign monk.
And as soon as Bodhidharma is in front of him, Emperor says, well, you know, I've constructed many monasteries, I have ordained many monks, I've had many scriptures copied, I've practiced diligently. What merit is there in that? And Bodhidharma says there is no merit.
And you know, I think it's worth thinking about this a little bit, that the emperor is definitely seeing his practice as this path to Buddhahood, this self transformation. He's accumulating merit by doing good deeds.
Whenever you do virtuous acts, you have virtuous thoughts, but especially when you show generosity to the Sangha, you earn there is good karma created which is stored as merit. So merit is not only it pushes you, pushes you, moves you forward in your path to Buddhahood, you become a more virtuous person and collect more merit and have more good karma and become more and more virtuous, purge yourself of the defilements of attachment and aversion, until one day you become enlightened. And clearly that sort of accumulative, let's say self transformation, that kind of practice is something that Emperor Wu had in mind. And that was in fact sort of the model for Buddhism from early days in India that you worked on developing good character, ethical behavior, you would do your meditation, you would do your study.
So Emperor who's always accumulating knowledge and understanding of the scriptures, and at some point out there you will wake up and Bodhidharma's view is a different one. It's the one that they'd never heard of before. But it's pretty familiar to us, this idea that no, we can awaken right now. You don't have to purify your mind before you can wake up. You can do it right now, just sit here, just be aware of whatever's going on in this moment, including your thoughts and feelings and desires, but don't be caught up in them. And that is the culmination of perfect enlightenment.
So he goes, well, you know, I don't know what you're talking about. There is no merit. There is only this vast, boundless, seamless reality.
There are no separate things, there are no separate, separate people that have merit.
There's no merit here. There's just this, this dependent co arising reality, moment by moment coming up, which can't be chopped up into pieces.
So that's why he says there's no merit.
No merit. Not just to answer the question.
He's saying, you know, you gotta stop thinking like this.
This is not how it works. This is not about accumulating understanding, accumulating virtue to reach awakening.
But Emperor Wu doesn't understand and he's a little taken aback. And I think this is where I think he wants to, he wants to debate with Bodhidharma, sort of show him who's who. Because he's the Bodhisattva, the Buddha heart Emperor. He's studied very hard, he has great knowledge of all of the scriptures. And so, you know, he says, what is the highest meaning of the holy truths?
You know, what is the fundamental essential teaching that leads us to holiness?
And Bodhidharma says, you know, vastness, emptiness, no holiness, There are no holy things, there are no holy teachings, there are no holy people.
Which is kind of a shock to the Emperor because he's clearly, you know, he's already asked the question, I mean, I've done all these good things and how much merit have I got? You know, how close am I to enlightenment? Am I there yet or am I near? How, how much have I got? And he says, you got nothing and you are not, there is no holiness, you have not accumulated any holiness.
But I think more fundamentally, he's not just answering the question, he's saying, look, it's if there's emptiness, there are no things, there are no separate things, there are no fixed things.
Then anything you can think, any concepts you have about the world, any thinking you have about the world doesn't really have some real thing. That it's referring to. Those words are empty too. You need to stop thinking like this.
You need to stop worrying about accumulating learning and accumulating merit in order to reach nirvana and come back to right here.
So the emperor is pretty taken aback again and he. But he comes back again.
He comes back one more time and says, okay, who's facing me?
You know, he's an expert. He's an expert on the two truths. Doctrine of form and emptiness are not separable. They're the same.
So he's kind of going, okay, foreign monk, you say everything is empty. You say there's no merit. Well, somebody's standing there in front of me.
Somebody's teaching the Dharma, somebody's holy. What do you. Who are you? Who are you? Then explain that. And Bodhidharma says, I don't know which isn't a great translation. The better translation is no idea or literally no knowing.
So it's not only.
He's not only talking about himself and the fact that he is not grasping the world himself conceptually. He has no view of himself, fixed conceptual view of himself, no idea of who he is, that he's not operating from that sort of thing, but he's letting go of them and approaching reality himself. He's saying emperor again, no idea, no knowing.
Stop the debate. This is not. You keep coming back with this. You have to stop.
And Emperor Wu did not understand.
So Bojidharma left the court, crossed the Yangtze river to the kingdom of Wei, and made his way up to Shaolin Monastery where he sat for nine years facing the wall.
Later, Emperor Wu, you know, decided, talked out of trying to bring Bodhidharma back. But he. He heard more about Bodhidharma and he came to appreciate him. He wrote a very nice poem for him when Bodhidharma died.
So.
But I think we. I certainly feel a lot of sympathy for Emperor Wu. And you have to admire him. He was. He was a sincere and accompl practitioner of Buddhism. But not only that, I mean, the way he approached Buddhism is something we have.
I do. I mean, I will go notwithstanding appreciating sitting in zazen, I certainly come back and say, well, you know, if I. I need to sit zazen a lot, I need to study a lot, I need to go to Ancient Dragon a couple of times a week, I need to sit Sachin's.
And when that happens, it's all going to be different, you know.
And then, you know, you sit back down and you go, wait a minute, wait a minute.
And you know, we can recognize this, and certainly there's no question that our practice brings about transformation.
But transformation doesn't bring about awakening.
Transformation is the expression.
It's a result of awakening.
But in our lives, it's also true. Two things are true.
One is that there will always be attachment, aversion and delusion, likes and dislikes, judgments on right or wrong, good or bad.
And, you know, and as we approach our world, there'll be feelings of hope and expectation and dread about what's going to happen next.
But what is also true is that we will wake up over and over and over again. And that waking up is. There's nothing.
Not like Emperor Wu seems to have expected that.
I got some holiness and some merit here, and then I got a little more down the road, and I got a little more. I got some understanding here. I keep working. I understand more. I understand more. I understand more. Our liberation, our taste of enlightenment in sitting is the same every time.
Sit down on the cushion the first time, and the first time we step back and let go of the thoughts and are just sitting here.
Here we are in this moment, in these surroundings, with this body, mind.
And after five years of practice, it's the same experience of zazen. Sitting here, experiencing the surroundings, our posture, our bodily sensations, our thoughts, our thinking, our emotions, desires, but waking up again and again and again.
So this is not one of those koans where, you know, the monk comes to the great teacher, like, you know, monk comes to Bodhidharma and says, help me out, teacher, or something like that. And Bodhidharma says something. He goes, oh, I'm awake. It didn't happen.
It did not. Ipro Wu did not understand.
But this message has survived and it's come to us, this message of awakening right here and right now on our cushion, and this experience of liberation right now.
So I'd be interested in any thoughts any of you might have about this story and how it resonates with you, your life and your practice.
Thank you.
[00:23:08] Speaker D: Nicole has round up.
[00:23:10] Speaker C: Oh, okay.
[00:23:11] Speaker B: I do.
[00:23:12] Speaker C: Yes.
[00:23:13] Speaker E: Good morning.
Thank you so much for this talk, Douglas.
Some of us are.
Well, all of us in this room and everywhere are working with the precepts. So there's the seminar on Thursdays, and it's my first time really, you know, studying the precepts and working with the precepts. And this talk really clarified and helped and coalesced some. Some things for me. I was reading this week and something kind of jumped out in my reading that, thinking about the precepts not as, like, prohibitions is very helpful because there will maybe always be these violations, if you'll call them that.
So just thinking about them, this practice more flexibly, not thinking about the, you know, the precepts as these, like, strict prohibitions, but these, like, inciting moments, opportunities for practice, and thinking about this waking up as ongoing in spite of or involving sort of violations.
And I was thinking in this, you know, in the instance of this case that you bring up the.
The fixity or fixations or accrual them, like the thought of accrual itself seems like a violation in a way.
So, yeah, I guess that's all I wanted to say. However, all over the place that might be. I have many notes to sit with from this talk that will go toward continuing to think about how to work with precepts as a human was in, in and out of good practice, maybe.
But thank you very much.
[00:24:58] Speaker C: Thank you.
[00:24:59] Speaker B: So. Thank you, Douglas.
I wondered what would have been a connecting conversation between Bodhidharma and Emperor Wu. What would have, you know, what might have been different that might have, you know, because in some ways it feels like maybe later on Emperor was a little bit awakened.
But I wondered about, you know, I thought both parties in this situation could have met each other just slightly differently.
So I just wondered if you have any thoughts about that.
[00:25:39] Speaker C: Yeah, I think that, you know, this is. It's.
It's hard to imagine this as something that occurred in real life, that surely Emperor was pretty sophisticated.
Bodhidharma could have explained his position better.
I think, you know, koans are an art form, and this follows the art form of not necessarily making it easier for us to practice.
I think that I would not have, if I had been Bodhidharma, a much more accomplished practitioner, Zen, whatever that would be.
I wouldn't have done it like that myself. Yeah.
And I would have said something like, even look this, when you do all of these things, when you study in this way, when you make donate to the Sangha in this way, with this sort of transactional approach of doing this in order to fix yourself and gain merit, is actually impeding your awakening right now.
Being caught up in this, grasping for it and hoping for attainment and imagining yourself in the future, imagining his future state, oh, if I study, I'm enlightened. These guys. He's imagining, at least to some extent, imagining the future, taking himself away from the reality of. Of here and now, this experience of in this moment and experiencing Buddha in this moment.
And that maybe that would have been more effective.
I Would have, you know, you would say, look, I'm not. It's a wonderful thing that you give money to the sangha. It's a wonderful thing that you.
You build these monasteries. It's a wonderful thing that you.
You study the Dharma, that you practice the Dharma.
But there would be a different approach, that you would do these things as an expression of your bodhisattva spirit and your. An expression of your awakening, having recognized the possibility of waking, the intent to awake.
That would probably.
I think that would be a much more helpful way to have approached it.
Yes. Arhenis.
[00:28:05] Speaker F: Oh, yes.
Oh, no.
I think that for me, like, I come here, I, you know, like, he's talking about the merits and the teaching.
And I see it more as actually those merits, those teaching, those practices, those are the one that are guiding you to realize that there is nothing, that there is emptiness. So there is a purpose for it, for me to do the practice, to do the merits, because it's a way. I don't know if I'm saying this right. It's a way to realize that really there is no merit, there is no practice.
But it's with that that I do that I will get to that knowledge or to that understanding that is like a tool to make me realize that there is nobody in front of me or there is nobody here.
So if we.
I was thinking about this about, you know, like, if we see it as a movie and we're. We're characters, and we all.
We had two characters. One character, he plays the role, does a wonderful performance, and the other character misses the. The point.
I think that the one that does the performance comes to the realization that he's not even the character, that he is the consciousness that is aware of the character, but there is nothing there.
So there is this emptiness that we are. But we had to do these practices.
We had to perform. We had to.
We had to express our life in the best way possible.
But knowing that what you're doing and the practices that you're doing, the merit that you're accumulating, is actually guiding you to understanding that there is nothing there.
So in that way, I see what I'm trying to say here is that even though, yes, there is no merit, there is no practice, there is no still, I find it. That is helpful to me to make me realize, to that understanding.
[00:30:25] Speaker C: That's all
[00:30:26] Speaker F: I wanted to say.
[00:30:27] Speaker C: Yeah. I think that it's kind of interesting that our, at least Soto Zen in particular, would say just the practice of zazen is the realization of culminated perfect enlightenment.
Sitting here with this experience of this moment as a whole is itself the experience of emptiness, that there are no separate things. But you don't necessarily understand that.
Dogen says, for example, you won't necessarily be aware of your own enlightenment.
You can do this and you don't necessarily have a conceptual understanding of what's going on.
And I think, yeah, that's one of the benefits maybe of study and doing virtuous acts. Living by the paramitas, the practice of kindness and generosity and compassion.
All of that, you know, has a reciprocal relationship to our practice that our awakening results in the expression of these bodhisattva acts and that in turn feeds our zazen and our awareness of being in this complete reality right now.
Yeah, So I would certainly not say don't do these acts, but I don't think I'd say we don't have to fix ourselves or do something to complete ourselves before we experience this awakening.
[00:32:23] Speaker D: Online we have Dennis and then Nicholas.
[00:32:26] Speaker C: I'm trying to find Dennis on the Scuvarians. Okay. Hi.
[00:32:29] Speaker G: Thank you for your talk this morning. It was helpful.
When you talk about this, one of the things that comes to mind for me is the word unconditional.
Is our practice, an unconditional practice is that I do it or I do it as much as possible without conditions. Could you comment on that?
[00:32:51] Speaker C: Well, I guess. What do you mean by we do it without conditions?
[00:32:57] Speaker G: Well, that I'm going to get something or I expect to get something from it. That's the condition.
So would you even use that term related to our practice?
[00:33:08] Speaker C: I'm going
[00:33:09] Speaker G: to do this in spite of I'm going to do this.
And it goes back to what Shaw Hocker used to say, you know, it's a good for nothing.
Sausin's good for nothing. I think that's what it was trying to express for me at least was, you know, the unconditional quality about what we do.
And as a human being, am I able to act unconditionally or how, or can I just aspire to it, you know, or do I practice it?
So it's just a thought.
[00:33:42] Speaker C: Yeah. I think the. I think that.
I think we don't try to, you know, our sort of touchstone is the. What Suzuki Roshi would say over and over again is that we practice for no gain, that there's not going to be some. That the practice itself is the. I don't know, we'll say the good.
It's hard to come up with another phrase, but I Think that, as I said, we don't have to fix ourselves.
We could feel all sorts of desire or daydreams about what it's going to be like to have this flash of awakening and everything will be good. I think if that comes up, we are aware of those thoughts and desires for awakening or the desire to escape from whatever problems I'm having right now and are feeling on the cushion and just letting those thoughts and hopes and expectations be there as part of this moment is. Is the liberation and the experience of the wholeness of this moment.
We don't have to purge ourselves of all. All attachment and aversion.
We incorporate it into our experience of the moment.
There was one more. Right.
[00:35:03] Speaker D: Nicholas.
[00:35:04] Speaker C: Nicholas. Oh, there's your hand. Okay.
[00:35:06] Speaker H: Good morning. Good
[00:35:07] Speaker C: morning.
[00:35:08] Speaker H: That was a great talk, Douglas.
It's. You know, there's a. There's so much there.
I mean, basically, I just feel like, you know, enlightenment is kind of like the booby prize, right? It's. It's this thing that's held out, but yet, you know, everything's empty and there's nothing to get. And, you know, it's like, why even I don't really concern myself with enlightenment or awakening because I just. I've never known anybody who was enlightened. I've been around for decades, never known, you know, anybody who's fully awakened. You know, it's. At the end of the day, we're all human. So, you know, why do I practice?
You know, I can cultivate compassion. I can cultivate patience. I can try to cultivate humility, thoughtfulness. You know, I can sitting zazen. I can explore my identities and deconstruct them and live in a more expansive way, you know, sometimes by seeing things differently.
But this, you know, it's. I don't know, just these. All these stories about getting enlightened and, you know.
Yeah, it's a kind of a bit of a fool's errand in a way. And I think that you're saying that as well. And obviously the teachings say that as well at the end of the day, too. So why are we so obsessed with it?
[00:36:49] Speaker C: Oh, we always have this thirst for escape from this life we have now. And achievement is some transcendent happy that's going to last forever. Once and for all, you have this big experience and happiness and understanding and peace sort of trickle down into everything in your life. Right.
There's plenty of evidence that that doesn't happen. I mean, this. I mean, we're starting to get away from that first generation of Japanese and Tibetan teachers who came to this country in the. In the 60s and 70s.
Those people, some of them were very impressive people, but they did a lot of bad things. Right.
We've got reason to be a little skeptical about this top down, explosive moment that trickles down through the rest of your life and transforms you into some saintly human being a little more. It's a little harder than that, and it's a little simpler than that too. I think that we wake up to this, into this moment of wholeness, and we try to live from that mind of wholeness.
Our life is.
Our life is not separate from the world. The whole world is.
Other people are our life. And we try to act from that, that we share a life.
And I think that experience of wholeness is, you know, maybe that's the best I can say about why we do this anyway.
[00:38:26] Speaker H: Well, yeah, and it's kind of found in community, outside of yourself, the sense of, you know, wholeness, you know, I don't know, being of service or. I don't know, it's complicated. But I. I really appreciated your talk and thought you, you know, spoke about these very hard to talk about topics in a really interesting way. So thanks.
[00:38:48] Speaker C: Thank you. I appreciated your comments, Howard.
[00:38:52] Speaker G: Thank you, Douglas, for your talk.
It's actually really funny that you gave a talk on this koan, because I was. I was literally just talking to my brother about this the other day. He and I will have spent many years looking at the Chinese for these koans and go, what the hell is that? Why did we. Why did they translate it like that? And I appreciated you bringing up that. I don't know is actually not a very good translation.
It was bugging me the other day. I'm like, oh, I never looked this up. What is the actual Chinese for this?
Cause I assumed it was a particular character and it wasn't. So I looked into it and your parse of it is more accurate.
[00:39:26] Speaker C: And
[00:39:26] Speaker G: it's interesting because ever since
[00:39:28] Speaker C: then
[00:39:28] Speaker G: and hearing
[00:39:28] Speaker C: it, I mean, the
[00:39:30] Speaker G: actual
[00:39:30] Speaker C: character has more sort of a definition
[00:39:33] Speaker G: about,
[00:39:33] Speaker C: like there's
[00:39:34] Speaker G: knowing in it too, but it's also
[00:39:35] Speaker C: like
[00:39:36] Speaker G: recognition
[00:39:36] Speaker C: or to
[00:39:37] Speaker G: recognize
[00:39:37] Speaker C: or to.
[00:39:39] Speaker G: Of consciousness.
[00:39:40] Speaker C: And so you're
[00:39:41] Speaker G: parts of it being
[00:39:42] Speaker C: like it's
[00:39:43] Speaker G: not even coming together
[00:39:44] Speaker C: yet. Not letting it come together, not letting it reify, to not conceptualize in a kind of way. I don't like, I don't know the guy kind of thing.
It hits
[00:39:53] Speaker G: a bit closer. And I found myself, when I was listening to you, kind of like putting myself in the different, like, well, I mean, really two characters shoes, right? And I imagine, like, what is it like being Emperor Wu in this. In this space? Like, I've got all these ideas about who I am. I've got all these ideas about what to do about this. I've got these desires, all these, like, conceits, right, about who I am and what I'm supposed to do. And suddenly I got this guy who I think. I think I know something about, I have
[00:40:20] Speaker C: assumptions about.
[00:40:21] Speaker G: I've reified
[00:40:22] Speaker C: this guy, I've
[00:40:23] Speaker G: conceptualized
[00:40:23] Speaker C: this guy, and it doesn't allow me to connect with him. And he goes, well, I don't know who the hell I am. I don't
[00:40:29] Speaker G: recognize.
[00:40:29] Speaker C: I
[00:40:29] Speaker G: don't recognize this
[00:40:30] Speaker C: either.
And I find that really freeing because
[00:40:33] Speaker G: I think that,
[00:40:34] Speaker C: I mean, I do this all the time with people. I do this with you.
[00:40:37] Speaker G: I do this with Hougetsu,
[00:40:38] Speaker C: I do this with Wade. I do this with Ruben. I do this with everybody in this room. I've done this in some way, shape or form, and it keeps me from actually connecting with people.
I just keep coming back
[00:40:48] Speaker G: to this.
In recent months, I've been sort
[00:40:51] Speaker C: of
[00:40:51] Speaker G: sinking further and further in my practice in some kind of way. And it wasn't an intentional thing of this conceit of the self and all the investments I have, all the desires I have and all the pain that's like, underneath all of it.
I don't know where I'm going with this, but I just really appreciate you talking about this and bringing this koan to light. It was just sort of a nice sort of synchronous thing of me looking this up sort of earnestly the other day out of confusion and sort of bringing myself back to this. Like, okay, like, but how are you actually being intimate with yourself or being intimate with other people?
What is getting in the way of that? And at least in my case, it's always my self conceit.
So thank you.
[00:41:33] Speaker C: Yeah.
There are a lot of situations in which the translations are questionable.
There's translations. I don't know.
Is Bodhidharma just speaking about himself or is he saying, don't know?
No, knowing is the way.
Not knowing no ideas is a practice instruction for the emperor, and it's something that appears in lots of other koans, right.
In the Mumukan, I think it's case 19 of everyday mind is the Way. Ordinary Mind is the way. When Xiao Zhou goes to his teacher Dantuan and says, what is. What is the dao? And he says, well, ordinary mind is the way. Do I direct myself toward it?
No. If you try to direct yourself toward it, it just recedes further away. Well, then how do I know what's the dao? He says, well, knowing is delusion.
You know, trying to put a label on something, put it in a box, compartmentalize it and separate it from other things is in error.
That takes you away from what is the whole wholeness of the moment or what, you know, the. Oh. Why did you come to the monastery? Why are you on pilgrimage? Why did you come to this monastery? I don't know. Not knowing is most intimate.
Don't get caught up in labels, descriptions, explanations, ranking.
Just be there.
[00:43:18] Speaker H: Can I say one other quick thing?
[00:43:20] Speaker C: Sure.
[00:43:21] Speaker H: Is, Is, Howard. Like what you just said is, is. Was really powerful for me because I, I, that's the, you know, this idea of intimacy with our. Our thoughts, our experience, our pain, our anger, you know, and the conceits of our identity that keep us separate from the world and others. That's. To me, what. Awake is a good definition of awakening, if there is such a thing as a definition. But it's powerful and simple, but not easy.
[00:43:59] Speaker C: We need to close down.
I think we're out of time.
[00:44:07] Speaker B: We'll do the four vows. But I wanted to also thank Nicholas for describing awakening as a booby prize
[00:44:15] Speaker H: and
[00:44:16] Speaker B: then awakening as the prize of wholeness. So thank you very much, Douglas.
[00:44:25] Speaker C: Okay.
Beings are numberless.
To free them, delusions are inexhaustible.
We vow to get through them.
Our monkey
[00:44:45] Speaker I: are faultless.
[00:44:48] Speaker C: We vow to enter them with ways unsurpassable.
Trivialize it being honorless.
We vow to free them.
Delusions are inexhaustible.
We
[00:45:13] Speaker I: vow to cut through them.
No matter.
Delusions are inexhaustible.